
Sometimes the inner critic has made a decision before we realise there was a choice to make.
We postpone an application, hold back an observation, or sign up for another training course. There may be good reasons, but I’m curious about the place we make these decisions from. Are we recognising and responding to learning needs, or following a voice that says: ‘I am not enough yet’?
The inner critic can quietly decide what we are ready for, what we are allowed to offer and how much of ourselves we bring to our work. Learning to recognise its influence gives us an opportunity to listen more fully to ourselves and choose how we want to respond.
I will be ready for MCC after one more training course
When I began considering my MCC application, I had accumulated around four thousand coaching hours. I had attended several coaching schools, explored different approaches and worked consistently with mentors. Yet I could always identify something else I needed to learn before I would be ready.
I loved learning and wanted to understand coaching through different perspectives. Alongside that curiosity, however, was another conversation: Who am I to call myself a master? What responsibilities would come with that? What if I could not live up to what people expected of an MCC?
My mentor coach, Belinda, invited me to consider applying. Her perspective helped me notice the distance between the work I had already done and the way I was seeing myself.
I had been treating mastery as if it guaranteed I would always know what to do and deliver an exceptional session every time. Understanding it as an ongoing practice changed my relationship with the MCC journey. I could take responsibility for my development, make mistakes, seek feedback and keep learning. There was room for me to be human within my commitment to developing coaching mastery.
Where the critic enters the coaching conversation
Across my inner critic webinars, we have explored how this voice appears through perfectionism, procrastination, comparison and the search for certainty. It can sound remarkably sensible: I should prepare more. I need a better question. I cannot let the client leave without a breakthrough.
Within a session, those instructions can affect the partnership. We may begin rehearsing our next question while the client is speaking. We may fill a silence because we worry that we are contributing too little, or push towards an insight because we want evidence that our coaching has value. Sometimes we hold back something we have noticed because we are afraid it will be wrong.
Our attention has shifted. We are still with the client, but part of us is occupied with evaluating our own performance, so we are not fully present. That leaves less space to hear the particular person in front of us and respond to what is emerging between us.
This is why I see working with the inner critic as an essential part of the journey towards mastery. Our relationship with ourselves influences the quality of our coaching and the space we can create with another human being.
Who else is on the stage when you’re coaching?
I can often see my inner critic taking up most of the stage in my mind.
Trying to make him disappear has not been particularly useful. Most of the time, he does not even speak; he simply stays there, in a sort of witnessing posture.
I’ve learned to acknowledge his presence and visualise “shrinking” him. This allows me to see the other characters and the wider context, and give them back their rightful places.
His “message” may contain something worth considering. Perhaps there is preparation to do, feedback to seek, or a fear of judgment around something important to me. The voice is there for a reason. I want to understand what it is telling me and decide what to do with that information.
There is a difference between recognising that I would like to develop a particular aspect of my coaching and concluding that I am inadequate as a coach. The first gives me something specific to work with. The second can cast a shadow over everything I already bring.
I can ask: What is useful in this message? What is it trying to protect? And what else do I know about myself that deserves to be heard?
How we meet ourselves when we notice our inner critic
Belinda often brings self-compassion into our conversations about mastery. I see the relevance of this most clearly in the moments when we recognise we have lost presence.
It is easy to turn that awareness into another criticism: I have done it again. I should be better at this by now.
We can spend the next few moments judging the very thing we have just noticed.
When we’re facilitating our Level 3 classes, Belinda and I practise meeting these moments with kindness. Noticing the inner critic's voice without judging ourselves further gives us an opportunity to return to full presence. Feeling our feet on the floor, taking a breath and reconnecting with the client can be enough to begin again.
The same quality matters when we review a coaching session recording. Can we recognise what we did well, as well as what we want to develop? Can we see the warmth, spaciousness or courage we brought, including qualities that feel so natural to us that we overlook them?
Self-compassion allows me to look more honestly at my work. I can acknowledge an intervention that did not serve the client, explore what was happening in me and choose something to practice. I can take the learning seriously while treating myself as a person who is learning.
That is also where mentoring, supervision, and a trusted learning community can be valuable. They offer perspectives beyond the verdict I may already have passed on myself.
A practice of returning to choice
When you notice the inner critic directing you, give yourself a moment to explore what is happening. You might begin with a recent session or a decision you have been postponing.
Notice the instruction
What exactly is the voice saying, and what is it leading you to do or avoid?
Observe its effect
Where has your attention gone? What happens in your body, your listening or your way of participating? Stay in touch with what emerges.
Discern what is useful information
Is there a specific learning need, a real constraint or something important you want to protect? What evidence supports the inner critic's message, and what remains an assumption?
Reposition the voice
Make room for the rest of what you bring. Which strengths, experience, talents and values are also relevant here?
Choose your response
Given what you now see, what would serve the client, your development or the contribution you want to make?
You may choose further preparation. You may choose to ask for support, offer an observation lightly or allow a silence to continue. You may take a step while some uncertainty remains.
Beyond the coaching room
The journey towards mastery offers many opportunities to practise this awareness, and its relevance reaches into the rest of our lives. The voice of the inner critic can shape whether we begin a project, express a need, share an idea or accept an opportunity that matters to us.
There is a larger question here: Whose life am I living?
The critic may remain part of our lives, and sometimes its information will be valuable. Yet I also want to hear my strengths, talents, passion and values, and take responsibility for the choice I make. Each time I notice what is directing me, I have an opportunity to reconnect with what matters and choose the place I want to respond from.
What has your inner critic already decided on your behalf, and what might you choose when you give the rest of yourself a voice?
If you think your inner critic might be sabotaging you or blocking your growth as a coach, there are many ways I can support you. I offer 121 mentoring and supervision, flexible group drop-in sessions, and an ICF-accredited Level 3 coaching programme for PCCs on the path to mastery. Please don't hesitate to get in touch.
Comments